Marquis Davis

Blockchain and Cryptocurrency’s Tug of War: Uncovering the Clash Between True Believers and Opportunistic Speculators

Blockchain can help people coordinate and share control. Speculative markets can reward promotion and concentrate control in many of the same hands.

Overlapping rings and directional forms.

Follow the incentive

People came to blockchain looking for ways to exchange value outside familiar gatekeepers. Some wanted open infrastructure they could help govern. Others saw a new market and an opportunity to trade. The same project can attract both groups. Trouble starts when the trade becomes the product and the people buying in cannot see what they own.

A rising price is easy to market. Maintaining a shared system takes slower work. Somebody has to make it usable, publish the terms, respond to disputes and explain which decisions belong to participants. Buyers and builders can ask how the project compensates that work, especially if interest in its token falls.

Look at control in practice

Who got the earliest allocation? Can insiders sell while everyone else is locked in? Who controls the money, and who can change the software or the rules? These questions help people understand whether a project can survive on what it actually does or depends on finding somebody new to buy in.

Open records can help surface conflicts. They cannot tell a reader whether a promoter’s claims about future returns are true. The people making those claims should have to answer for what they sold and disclose the interests that shape the pitch.

Leave room for the work worth doing

Shared records, cooperatives and new ways to allocate resources deserve to be tested on their own merits. The useful questions are specific. Who has gained access? Are decisions easier for participants to verify? Where does the value accrue over time? Those answers give us something solid to judge after the excitement fades.

Read next

All writing